When I was 13, precocious and combative, she told me I was an incomplete person in a very superior tone of voice. I had already unraveled the mystery of adult superiority by that time, concluding that they weren't usually superior to me, especially if I got them really angry and irrational. She was really angry and irrational much of the time. During a routine argument over walking my dog, she screamed that until I could vote, I was an incomplete person and had no right to talk back to her in this way. Underscoring her completeness, of course, was the fact that she, a seventy year old woman, was engaging with me, a 13 year old, in a shouting match over the safety of walking my dog -- alone, which I was set on -- through her Schenectady neighborhood. (Several years ago I put fingers to keyboard about the type of riffraff resides in Schenectady, and as I've been integrating the archives from my first blog into this one, you can check it out here.) Whether she was right, or I was, is irrelevant. The point here, in case I've been hiding the ball, is that Grandmother's composure and reasoning was inadequate to withstand even the challenges made by my thirteen year old rhetoric, and my distaste for her disposition grew steadily as I grew older.
Sadly, she hasn't, as the saying goes, aged gracefully. The older she gets, the more bitter and oddly emotional she becomes. During the same visit when I was 13, I noticed that she cried as we pulled out of her driveway in our Nissan minivan, despite treating us -- and especially me -- to a barrage of orders and snide criticisms during the course of our visit. Each year after that, she repeated this behavior -- we would get hugged and kissed and "sweathearted" when we arrived, and she would cry, sometimes hysterically, when we left, but never did she demonstrate kindness or love during the body of the trip. Around this time, my sisters and I started making inside jokes and commiserating about her treatment of us and the weird crap she'd say. (I am not even go to delve into the things she's said to or about my older sister, who had the distinct displeasure of living with her for a long period of time; let me just say that Grandmother hasn't been kind and she's lucky that my sister has more of a sense of familial duty than I have.)
Despite my antipathy toward her, I have always tried to remain cordial to Grandmother and to keep the peace when she's around -- that's my mature side speaking. In reality, I am a two-faced thirteen year old telling her how nice it is to see her while making snide comments to my sisters out of the corner of my mouth (she doesn't hear very well) about her general lack of sight, tact, and continence. Incomprehensibly, she tries to compare herself to me at every opportunity, feeling, perhaps that others will think more highly of her if she can show some similarity to me. Or, maybe she wants some attribution for how I've turned out. Or, it's even possible that she's trying to bring me down a peg. Who knows? (One minor example of this involved me dyeing my hair a dark reddish brown and her claiming that I must have inherited it from her mother. My sister and I just kept our amusement at this quietly to ourselves.) Her comparisons always involve her negative traits, like being overweight, having bad feet, lacking musical ability, and almost never the positive things that have actually made me successful, which she also shares, like intelligence, determination, outspokenness. I hate to break it to her, but her hammer toe, even if it were inherited by me, is not responsible for my six figure salary.
Recently, she moved to Maryland to be nearer to my parents. In honor of her move, which has been very challenging for my older sister, I thought I would compile a little "best of the worst" list of my favorite Grandmotherisms that I've been blessed to have directed at me through the years.
"You're an incomplete person...you have no right to talk back to your elders until you can vote!"
"When I was your age and about your weight, my boyfriend called me 'butterball.'"
While I sang Christmas carols: "Stop! Stop! [then, laughing] You know, I never could carry a tune in a bucket, either."
"I recognize those feet; do you have a hammer toe?"
While I tried on my wedding dress: "You need a girdle with that dress."
After trying on the wedding dress, as I ate a single piece of chocolate: "That isn't helping you lose 10 pounds."
"I need a pad, I'm soaked!!" (OK, this one isn't a comment to me or about me, merely something I found hilarious that I quote at every opportunity to my sisters. Mom finally laid the smack down about needing to wear diapers instead of treating her "little problem" with maxi pads.. this after years of having to cover all of our furniture with plastic before she'd visit, including the mattress that she slept on -- my mattress, I should say.)
"I've lost 5 pounds." (Again, not to or about me, but merely something humorous she says almost every time she gets Mom on the phone. Mom has hilariously commented that there wouldn't be anything left of her if she'd actually lost all of the 5 pounds-es she'd claimed to. Note: there's plenty left of her.)